The Prices in Green are the estimated values of the Item.
Anything Underlined is a Link to a picture of that item.

Some quick notes about Zippos. First off, like many other items, the prices on Zippos vary. If it is “sealed,” unused, and in it’s OG Black case, they would possibly go for more than the listed price. If they aree visibly used, they could go for lower.

Also be awake of the fakes. There are quite a few on ebay like this, and some local stores even take plain zippos and put stickers on them! I’m not naming any names (Rock of Ages), but if you wander into a store (Rock of Ages) and see that the Hatchetman only takes up the bottom half of the Zippo and doesn’t go top to bottom, you’re in this store (Rock of Ages).

Also to note: At the Gathering 2001, they were supposed to sell Fuck Off and Superballs Zippos, but I never saw them. So, if you in fact saw them or have pictures of them, please email us ASAP.

Psychopathic Hatchetman
Versions: 1) Chrome Red
Hatchetman $30+
2) Black
Red Hatchetman $30+
3) Grey
Red Hatchetman $25+
Comments: These are actually fairly newer
compared to the Joker Cards zippos, but I figured that they are probably the
most popular and recognizable, so why not start out with them. I believe they
started selling these around the Jeckel era, because in the older merch catalogs,
these were not available in any form. If you know different, let us know.
The Grey, sometimes known as “brushed” version was for sale at the Gathering
2003, then later came onto the Web Store.
Carnival of Carnage
Versions: 1) Chrome Carnival
of Carnage $30+
2) Black
Carnival of Carnage $30+
3) Blue
Carnival of Carnage $25+
Comments: These, along with the Ringmaster,
were the first Zippos put out by Psychopathic I do believe, in mid-1995. The
Chrome ones have been on the Web Store though, so “reprinted” or not, there
are probably more of those floating around than black ones. The Blue Zippos
debuted in August of 2002.
Ringmaster
Versions: 1) Brass Ringmaster
$25+
2) Black
Ringmaster $30+
Comments: Along with the COC, these were
the OG zippos produced by Psychopathic. I always thought the Brass ones were
rarer, but what the hell do I know? They are on the web store (as of August
2002) so they can’t be that rare.
Riddle Box
Versions: 1) Chrome RiddleBox
$25+
2) Black
RiddleBox $30+
3) Chrome
RiddleBox (Reversed Colors)
$55+
4) Black
RiddleBox (Reversed Colors)
$55+
5) Purple
RiddleBox $25+
6) Brushed
RiddleBox $25+
Comments: Here we go. The regular ones
here were sold from the catalogs, at shows, etc. Then come along the Reversed
Color Zippos, and like the CDs of the same “misprint,” these are fairly valuable
on the market. The Purple ones debuted on the Web Store in August 2002.
Great Milenko
Versions: 1) Chrome Red
Milenko $30+
2) Black
Red Milenko $30+
3) Chrome
Purple Milenko $30+
4) Black
Purple Milenko $30+
5) Chrome
Green Milenko $30+
6) Black Green
Milenko $30+
7) Chrome
Gold Milenko $45+
8) Black
Gold Milenko $55+
9) Grey
Red Milenko $25+
Comments: Ah, much like the CDs and shirts,
you can find a ton of different combinations of Milenko colors. I am also
pretty sure that there is a Black w/ Green Milenko zippo, as that would only
make sense. Of all of them, like most items, the Gold Milenko are a tad more
sought after. The Grey Milenko debuted in August of 2002, and is the first
“brushed chrome” zippos released by Psychopathic, so I am told by PT contributer
twiztidpanda@hotmail.com
House of Horrors Faces
Versions: 1) Chrome Violent
J $40+
2) Chrome
Shaggy $40+
3) Black
Violent J $30+
4) Black
Shaggy $30+
Comments: I assume that these were sold
during, or right around the HOH tour/era, which would be 1998. I also believe
that Rock of Ages in Detroit sold these at one time, much like they did many
other Zippos.
Twiztid Mostasteless Letters
Versions: 1) Chrome Mostasteless
Letters $45+
2) Black
Mostasteless Letters $45+
Comments: It didn’t take long for Twiztid
to get their own Zippo. These are fairly rare, and I am not sure if there
were ever any other colors released.
Twiztid Mostasteless Faces
Versions: 1) Chrome Mostasteless
Faces $40+
2) Black
Mostasteless Faces $40+
3) Brushed Mostasteless
Faces $45+
Comments: The famous Faces picture also
made it to Zippo form, as these quickly became one of the more popular Zippos
among Juggalos. Later in the game, we get the Brushed gimmick to add to these.
Note the Black ones were reprinted, and you can tell the difference by looking
at the bottom of the Zippo, as well as the case it comes in.
Amazing Jeckel Brothers
Versions: 1) Chrome Jack
Jeckel $25+
2) Chrome
Jake Jeckel $25+
3) Black
Jack Jeckel $30+
4) Black
Jake Jeckel $30+
5) Red
Jake Jeckel $30+
6) Brushed
Jack Jeckel $30+
7) Brushed
Jake Jeckel $30+
Comments: Two Jeckel brothers; two sets
of Zippos. These were available on the AJB tour I believe, and can be found
on the Web Store also. In 2008/2009, we get a few new zippos for those Amazing
Jeckel Brothers.
Bizzar Bizaar $25+
Comments: This Zippo debuted at the Gathering
2001 if I am not mistaken.
Twiztid Freek Show Faces
$45+
Comments: I have not really seen many
of these around, so I assume they are pretty rare. I also do not know if they
come in Solid Black, or if the faces come in any other colors. As always,
any info, hit us up.
Twiztid Serial Killaz
$$+
Comments: This Zippo was auctioned off
on Twiztid.com in December of 2001, and sold for 255 dollars.
Dark Lotus $25+
Versions: 1) Black Ice
Dark Lotus $85+
2) Chrome
Dark Lotus $30+
3) Brushed
Dark Lotus $30+
Comments: The “Ice” colored Zippo debuted
on the Web Store in August of 2002. After the Opaque Brotherhood was among
us, we received two new zippos in the chrome and brushed variety.
The Wraith: Shangri-La
Versions: 1) Grey Wraith:
Shangri-La $25+
2) Blue
Wraith: Shangri-La $10+
Comments: This first Zippo dropped on
the Web Store in mid-January 2003. The Blue one was available at some bootleg
website when The Wraith first dropped, but then the Web Store started to carry
it in May of 2003 for 10 bucks.
The Wraith: Hell’s Pit
$25+
Comments: In the aftermatch of Hell’s
Pit, this zippo surfaced.
Rydas $25+
Comments: Finally, the Rydas get some
Zippo love.
Blaze$25+
Comments: It’s about damn time Blaze finally
got his own zippo. Sporting the ever fresh Clockwork Gray logo, this can be
used for all your fire needs.
Boondox $25+
Comments: Represent for the southern sensation
Boondox with this fresh zippo. A first for Psy zippos, this one is more of
a battle damaged brass.
Bang Pow Boom
Versions: 1) Black Bang
Pow Boom $25+
2) Chrome
Bang Pow Boom $25+
3) Chrome
Bang Pow Boom $25+
4) Chrome
Spectrum $25+
5) White
Bang Pow Boom $25+
6) Blue Cerulean
$25+
Comments: With a Bang, these zippos appeared
on the web store, shortly after the release of the return of the Dark Carnival,
Bang Pow Boom. We have 6 off the bat, many thanks to CDTodd for snatching pictures for us.